An Aural Analysis of the New Album by We Are Scientists, With Love and SqualorDork PhD, Bitchdork University, New YorkAbstract: The debut album by the much-hyped Brooklyn-based band, We Are Scientists, was listened to in order to determine how good it was. It was found to be quite shit.
Materials and Methods: The CD "With Love and Squalor" was purchased from Kims Video & Music, imported into iTunes, transferred onto an iPod, and listened to twice.
Results and Discussion: The sample was first analyzed for its constituent parts and influences. Contrary to previous reports (
Spin, 2005) We Are Scientists do not "mix punk, funk, and a lil' bit of disco to yield a shiny, metallic bar of infectious, genre-bending rock". Instead, the sample was found to contain large amounts of poor quality commercial pop-rock punctuated with substandard Green Day-influenced hooks and choruses. The album was next assessed for danceability and was found to have a net danceability value of zero. Again, this is in contrast to previously published results (
NY Times, 2006). The reason for this discrepancy is likely due to the common misperception within indie-rock circles that music played at a relentlessly high tempo is directly proportional to danceability. The two values are, in fact, completely unrelated. Finally, the album was assessed for it's lyrics, which were found to be embarassingly awful, including, but by no means limited to, "What's the point of medication?/Only makes me wish that I were dead". The relationship of many of these lyrics to the poetry of 15-year olds is worthy of further study.
Although the album was only listened to twice, we are confident that our analysis (and score of
3/10) is much more accurate than previous studies (
Pitchfork, 2005). We were unable to test the album through additional listenings due to its extreme shiteness.
Conclusions: American bands should not try to make jerky, angular, post-punk, punk-funk. They couldn't do it the first time around and, so far, they haven't managed to do it this time either. Such music is much better left to the Brits. Also, in future, Dork should not be taken in by either hype or cute album covers, in order to avoid writing further angry reviews.